SalemNews.com, Salem, MA

Election Forum

October 24, 2012

Our view: No on Question 1

Don’t be too hard on yourself if you’re confused by Question 1, the so-called Right to Repair bill, on the Nov. 6 ballot. There are a lot of moving parts.

As written, the measure requires that auto companies share with independent repair shops the computer software codes that keep their vehicles running. The codes are the property of the companies (think Ford, General Motors and Toyota), meaning drivers often need to get repairs done at dealerships, where the work costs more.

If the ballot question is approved Nov. 6, the auto industry would have to immediately turn over code information to independent repair shops and would have until 2015 to satisfy a mandate that all new cars sold in the state include an onboard diagnostic and repair system that can be accessed with a standard laptop computer.

Given the high cost of auto repairs, this seems like a slam dunk for drivers.

The issue isn’t that simple. Lawmakers and the auto industry reached a deal of their own in the waning moments of the last legislative session. They believe their compromise, which pushes the onboard diagnostic system mandate to 2018 and protects trade secrets and security measures like electronic keys, is better for all involved. They are urging citizens to vote no on the ballot question, allowing the legislative compromise to take effect. Even if voters approve the ballot question, the Legislature has the option of tossing it in favor of its own bill anyway.

Further confusing the issue is that groups such as AAA, which helped craft the compromise legislation, have backed out and now say they want the ballot question to pass.

So voters can approve Question 1 and its stronger tilt toward independent shops. Or they can vote no and allow the compromise to which those shops and large automakers agreed. We think both sides should stick to the compromise, which will benefit consumers and local small businesses while protecting the trade secrets large auto companies need to compete. We recommend a No vote on Question 1.

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Election Forum

Local News
  • Salem extends principal search SALEM -- Superintendent Stephen Russell has extended the search for three new principals, arguably the most important personnel decisions he will make in his three years as head of the public schools. Russell is about to hire principals to guide turn

    April 24, 2014

  • 140423_SN_KYU_CROSSWALK A safer place to cross

    PEABODY -- A little more than a year after tragedy struck, the new pedestrian traffic signal in front of St. Adelaide's Parish is installed and operational. "My dad worked his whole life in the service of his community, church and country, and it giv

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo 5 Stories

  • MBTA proposes commuter-rail fee increase SALEM -- The train to Boston is about to get more expensive. Across-the-board fare increases recently proposed by the MBTA would raise the price of single trips on the commuter rail by 25 to 50 cents and the cost of monthly passes from between $10 fo

    April 24, 2014

  • Unrepentant serial drunken driver gets 31/2 to 5 years PEABODY -- Despite what a judge and prosecutor called an attempt to "hijack" the proceedings in his case, a serial drunken driver from Peabody was sentenced to state prison yesterday. Right up to the end, Peter Hurley, 53, was adamant that he'd done

    April 24, 2014

  • pipes1 Sewerage repair delay sparks worry MARBLEHEAD -- Serious concerns are building over delays in the repair of a sewer pipe connecting Marblehead to the South Essex Sewerage District in Salem. The need for replacing the two pipes became apparent in March 2013, when one began to leak int

    April 24, 2014 2 Photos