SalemNews.com, Salem, MA

Local News

April 11, 2014

Beverly case sets precedent

Supreme Judicial Court rules on what constitutes a 'building'

SJC Decision: Sheehan vs Weaver by Salem News

BEVERLY — William Sheehan admitted he had a lot to drink that night, two days after Christmas in 2007, when he fell from a third-floor landing outside his apartment on Rantoul Street in Beverly.

As he fumbled with his keys, he leaned against a rotted railing. It gave way, and he fell backward to the ground, leaving him with severe injuries.

Later, a Housing Court jury would conclude that while Sheehan was negligent — his blood alcohol level was more than three times the legal limit for driving — so were his landlords, David and Jean Weaver. The landlords were ordered to pay him $145,000 for their share, 60 percent, of the negligence.

But the jury went further, finding that under the state building code, the landlords were liable because the property had 18 building code violations. That conclusion was based on a legal theory known as strict liability, and it meant Sheehan was entitled to additional compensation from the landlord.

The Housing Court judge let the verdicts stand.

But yesterday, the Supreme Judicial Court concluded that 140 Rantoul St., a mixed-use commercial and residential structure, is not a “building” under that section of the building code. Instead, they treated it more like a private residence, despite the presence of a chiropractic office on the first floor. The court, in ruling on the Weavers’ appeal, reversed the part of the jury’s verdict that held the Weavers strictly liable.

The decision, written by Justice Fernande Duffly, concluded that because that section specifically lists types of buildings it covers as “a place of assembly, theater, special hall, public hall, factory, workshop, manufacturing establishment or building,” structures that are not on that list are not included.

Salem lawyer Louis Muggeo said the decision is bad news for his client, Sheehan, but potentially good news for other plaintiffs.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Local News

AP Video
Judge Ponders Overturning Colo. Gay Marriage Ban Airlines Halt Travel to Israel Amid Violence NYPD Chief Calls for 'use of Force' Retraining VA Nominee McDonald Goes Before Congress Bush: Don't Worry, Sugarland Isn't Breaking Up US Official: Most Migrant Children to Be Removed Police Probing Brooklyn Bridge Flag Switch CDC Head Concerned About a Post-antibiotic Era Raw: First Lady Says `Drink Up' More Water Courts Conflicted Over Healthcare Law Holder Urges Bipartisanship on Immigration Raw: Truck, Train Crash Leads to Fireball US Airlines Cancel Israel Flights Obama Signs Workforce Training Law Crash Victims' Remains Reach Ukraine-held City Diplomatic Push Intensifies to End War in Gaza Cat Fans Lap Up Feline Film Festival Michigan Plant's Goal: Flower and Die Veteran Creates Job During High Unemployment
Comments Tracker