, Salem, MA


August 30, 2013

Mammoth mystery spills over to Plum Island


The environmental organization, called Group for the East End, thought the clip referred to the New York island and sent the clip to the government agency that was conducting the report. When it received only a short mention in the final document, the group sent it to the New York media. It became a sensation.

New York media outlets such as Newsday picked up the story, and the bones became bones of contention for the opposition. The Group for the East End called upon the government to conduct archaeological fieldwork to discover more about the bones and other ancient remains that might be on the island. Paleontologists speculated on the possibility of valuable prehistoric finds on the island, based on the bones story.

“It was really big, because it was picked up by a lot of environmental groups that were opposing the sale,” Fleming said. “They latched onto this story.”

But Fleming said his suspicions were aroused from the outset.

“As soon as I saw it in the paper, I knew it was wrong,” he said.

The clue was a reference to the bones being discovered near a lifesaving station. Fleming and the historical society had been conducting extensive research on Plum Island for a book the society plans to publish, and the research showed there wasn’t a lifesaving station on the island in 1879.

“It couldn’t possibly be the same Plum Island,” he said.

But Fleming learned there was a Plum Island that had a lifesaving station in 1879 — our local Plum Island. Fleming made his information known to the local media, and the Southampton Press published stories this week casting doubt on the origin of the bones.

There was still one piece of the puzzle missing. The clip that started the controversy had only been found in the Long Islander newspaper. This week, The Daily News of Newburyport sought to find local evidence to confirm Fleming’s contention.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Local News
  • 140724_SN_DLE_PEM1-1 Peabody Essex Museum severs ties with Gordon College

    SALEM -- The Peabody Essex Museum announced Thursday that it had ended its longstanding collaboration with Gordon College and its museum studies program, saying the school's attitude toward gay and lesbian individuals conflicts with its fundamental values.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo 7 Stories

  • Cop wants pension credit for lifeguard work BOXFORD -- A veteran Boxford police officer is trying to boost his retirement pension by getting credit for his summer job as a lifeguard nearly four decades ago. In a letter to a state appeals board, John Iannazzo said working as a lifeguard for the

    July 25, 2014

  • 140724_SN_DLE_BRIMBAL3 Residents skeptical of Brimbal Avenue plans

    BEVERLY -- Neighborhood residents turned out in healthy numbers Thursday for an open meeting to see and discuss new design plans for the Brimbal Avenue/Route 128 interchange. Concerns ranged from biking and pedestrian safety to tax dollars spending a

    July 25, 2014 6 Photos 9 Stories

  • 140724_SN_DLE_GRIFFIN6 Peabody's new police chief receives upbeat welcome

    PEABODY -- More than 100 family, friends, well-wishers, city officials and police officers lined Wiggin Auditorium in City Hall yesterday afternoon to applaud the swearing in of former Salem Capt. Thomas Griffin as the city's new police chief. "Today

    July 24, 2014 8 Photos

  • Drama builds today in Market Basket saga

    July 25, 2014