In an age when consumers can buy goods and services anywhere, right from their smart phones, it is bad policy for the Commonwealth to impose significantly higher employment costs on their businesses than exist in other states.
If the Senate version becomes law, our Main Street retail stores will be particularly harmed. It is a little-known fact, but retail businesses in Massachusetts are required to pay time-and-a-half pay on Sundays. (Massachusetts is one of only two states in the nation with this requirement — Rhode Island is the other.) That means that the retailer minimum wage on Sundays will actually be $16.50, if the minimum wage is $11, while it remains $7.25 in New Hampshire.
Not only is this requirement expensive and outdated, but it is a major driver for why Massachusetts teen employment has plummeted from 53 percent in 1999, to 26.8 percent in 2012. Retailers just can’t afford to hire unskilled teenage workers.
Unintended consequences can occur when you make it too costly for employers to operate their businesses. Job reductions are certain to happen when you raise employers’ costs without them also seeing a similar percentage increase in sales. People lose track of the fact that government employers, health care facilities and universities can all raise payroll by forcing higher costs on entrapped taxpayers, health insurance consumers, and college students. But private employers don’t have that luxury since their customers are not trapped and generally have unlimited purchasing options.
Although few would argue against some increase in the minimum wage, balance is needed if our businesses are going to stay competitive and healthy in a very soft economy.
Balance should take the form of repealing the retail Sunday premium pay requirement; creating a “teen wage” below the minimum so our youth can have some hope for getting that first job; reducing size of the increase to an affordable level; and reforming the abused unemployment insurance system.
The employer community is hoping that common sense and good public policy will carry the day in this election year, rather than the political pressure from powerful union special interests.
Jon B. Hurst is the president of the Retailers Association of Massachusetts.