Barrymore sets high standard in her models as talk show host

Drew Barrymore's first show on Monday features former "Charlie's Angels" co-stars Cameron Diaz and Lucy Liu as guests, along with Adam Sandler. (Charles Sykes/Invision/AP)

Drew Barrymore is setting a high standard for herself as she joins the world of daytime talk show hosts on Monday. She wants to emulate David Letterman and Howard Stern as interviewers.

Both men became media stars through their comedy — ironic for Letterman, crude for Stern. Yet, each man, as their careers lengthened, became particularly skilled at disarming guests to get beyond stilted “what have you been up to lately” conversations.

“We’re all human beings on this planet going through our lives and our journeys, and there’s a way to connect through that,” Barrymore said. “We don’t have to poke. I’m not looking to mess someone over. But at the same time, I just like to go in beneath the layers. I can’t stand the surface. I’ve never lived in that space.”

“The Drew Barrymore Show,” retrofitted for the coronavirus era, is being distributed by CBS Television. It will air live at 9 a.m. in cities like New York, Boston, Philadelphia and Miami and at 2 p.m. in Chicago, Dallas and San Francisco and others.

Several bold-faced names will help the 45-year-old actress through her crucial first week: Reese Witherspoon, Jane Fonda, Charlize Theron and Tyra Banks — and, on the first show alone, former co-stars Cameron Diaz, Lucy Liu and Adam Sandler.

Letterman and Stern developed their skills through years of hard work. For Barrymore, the hope is that likability and the audience’s familiarity with a star they’ve watched grow up since she was a 7-year-old in “E.T.” will give her the chance to learn by doing.

Bill Carroll, a veteran television consultant and expert in the syndication market, said that he’s impressed that Barrymore is shooting high.

“It’s good to look at modeling yourself after someone who is an unconventional interviewer,” he said. “Both of these men turned out to be excellent but unconventional in the way they approach things.”

Kelly Clarkson's recent success has given hope to people trying to get into the competitive world of syndicated talk, he said.

CBS' promotion of Barrymore's show hearkens back to her appearance with Johnny Carson as a little girl in the 1980s, a reminder to viewers that they know her. Yes, some may regard Barrymore as slightly loopy and hippie-dippie (“we’re all human beings on this planet”), but it’s more endearing than annoying.

The daughter of actor John Barrymore went through drug rehabilitation at an age most people worried about braces, as well as three divorces and motherhood, all in the public spotlight. She starred in movies like “The Wedding Singer” and “50 First Dates,” playing big-hearted characters it's impossible to root against.

She's had memorable moments as a talk show guest, like in 1995 when she danced on the table and flashed Letterman, her secret crush.

“Everyone my age has grown up with her,” said Elaine Bauer Brooks, head of development for CBS Television. “She lives her life in front of all of us. She's had her mistakes and her wins, and she's kind of owned them all along the way. There's a warm feeling about her and a sense of wanting her to win.”

Barrymore, who most recently produced and starred in the Netflix series “Santa Clarita Diet,” said the time was right to try a talk show. She'll have a schedule that's a better fit for a single mom raising two girls than most entertainment jobs.

Her show will originate from New York, where she lives now. It will air live in the morning to be responsive to what is going on in the world, but that's only to a point. She'll concentrate on celebrity, self-help and comedy segments and leave politics to others.

“I find politics extremely alienating to one side or the other, depending on who's watching,” she said, “and I don't want to make people feel not welcomed here or judged or disliked.”

Makers of “The Drew Barrymore Show” had to adjust on the fly to COVID-19. There won't be a studio audience, although they will try to link to an audience at home electronically. Through technology, Barrymore will be able to interview a guest who seems to be sitting in a comfy chair across from her, even if they're actually across the country.

Barrymore described herself as a “naughty” talk show guest through the years for avoiding the pre-show interview, where guests discuss in advance the seemingly spontaneous stories they'll tell later when the cameras are on.

Barrymore prized true spontaneity — “I like to go in blind and play because life is just too short not to” — but now she'll be on the other side. And, yes, her staff will conduct pre-show interviews. It's helpful to know how far someone will be willing to go in addressing certain topics, she said.

“I've had all my stuff out there, and I know how raw and vulnerable it feels,” she said. “I don't want to make people feel that way. But I do want to talk about stuff. I'm not shy. I haven't had the luxury of being shy in my life.”

Recommended for you